When Hollywood casts your sustainable product by accident… What is unpaid placement really worth?

Written By Michael Stausholm, Founder and CEO, SproutWorld & owner of the global patent on plantable writing instruments

 

A few weeks ago, someone from our US team went to see Spider-Man: Brand New Day. About three quarters of the way through the film, she noticed something that made her look twice: MJ, played by Zendaya, was sitting on a couch doodling with a pencil that looked very familiar. She contacted us, and I went to the cinema myself to see it.

 

Having looked at plantable Sprout pencils almost every day for the past 13 years, I am 99% certain that it is one of ours. I say 99% because we have no official confirmation from the production, and that distinction matters. If it is our plantable pencil, what makes the story unusual is that we had absolutely nothing to do with it. We didn’t pay for product placement, we didn’t have a partnership with the production, nobody contacted us and we didn’t even know it might happen. That made me wonder: what is accidental product placement actually worth?

 

When brands pay to be seen

According to Forbes, Spider-Man: Brand New Day generated an estimated $309 million in media value from 165 brand partnerships. Brands clearly see significant value in being associated with major entertainment properties, and many spend substantial amounts to secure that exposure. Against that backdrop, our experience presents an interesting counterexample. If a small company can apparently end up in a blockbuster without paying for the privilege, is that exposure worth the same as a carefully negotiated placement? Or is it potentially more valuable because it was never bought? The obvious answer is to assume we have hit the jackpot. Zendaya, Spider-Man and potentially millions of viewers is hard to beat. But exposure alone doesn’t tell us very much.

 

Exposure is not the same as impact

Since the film was released, we have looked at website traffic, sales, searches and social media mentions. So far, we haven’t seen a dramatic increase that we can confidently attribute to the film.

That is perhaps the more interesting part of the story. A product can potentially be seen by millions of people without them noticing the brand, remembering it or taking any action afterwards.

We have, however, noticed more business enquiries, particularly from the US, with companies asking for quotes for Sprout pencils. It is too early to say whether this is connected to the film, but it raises an interesting question: how should brands actually measure the value of product placement? Is it impressions? Brand association? Cultural relevance? Search behaviour? Or ultimately sales?

 

The value of being chosen

There is also a difference between being placed and being chosen. Paid placement gives brands control over where and how their products appear, which can be valuable when it is part of a wider campaign. If MJ really is using a plantable Sprout pencil, however, I rather like the idea that someone working on the production simply looked at it and thought: That’s the kind of pencil MJ would use. To me, that is more interesting than knowing that we had paid to put it there. But there is a trade-off. With accidental placement, you have no control and may not even know it happened. You also have no guarantee that audiences will notice.

 

What smaller brands can learn

For smaller companies, that may be the most interesting lesson of all. You cannot compete with global brands on the size of their marketing budgets, but you can create products that are distinctive enough to be noticed and relevant enough to belong naturally in people’s lives. Our plantable pencil was never designed to become a movie prop. It was designed to challenge the idea that a pencil has to become waste when you are finished with it. If one of our pencils really has ended up in the hands of MJ, that is a wonderful and slightly surreal bonus. But I don’t think the most interesting question is whether we got into Spider-Man for free. It is what happened after someone noticed us. You cannot always buy attention, and you cannot always measure its value immediately. But if your product gives people a reason to care, even an accidental moment of visibility can start a conversation around sustainability – and that’s a good thing in itself.